Can I Substitute Olive Oil For Vegetable Oil In Brownies- Fully Explained!

Last Updated on July 12, 2022 by

When preparing brownies, you discover a necessary ingredient is missing. Now and then, you may need to be inventive, whether you’re low on eggs, lacking in chocolate, or using the wrong oil. But what if you have olive oil and your brownie recipe calls for vegetable oil? Do the two oils have the same uses? Can I substitute olive oil for vegetable oil in brownies?

Yes, you can. Olive oil adds a delicious and somewhat bitter flavor to brownies, making it a fantastic vegetable oil replacement. Extra virgin olive oil should not be used to make brownies since it does not work as well in brownies as other types of olive oil.

Why Vegetable Oil Is Used In Brownies

Consider the function of vegetable oil in brownies before determining which oil is ideal and whether or not they can be used interchangeably. The major fat in brownies is oil, which makes them soft and gooey and prevents clumping in the batter. You need fat if you want smooth, creamy brownies!

Since vegetable oil often has a relatively neutral flavor, the rich chocolate flavor of the brownies will be allowed to come through. Additionally, vegetable oil is preferable since it contributes to the fattier-than-cakey texture of fudgy brownies and does not aerate batter as butter could.

Can I Substitute Olive Oil For Vegetable Oil In Brownies

You’ll be happy to know that your favorite brownie recipe can be prepared using olive oil, whether you’re seeking a healthy alternative or have run out of vegetable oil. Olive oil is comparable to vegetable oil in terms of density and viscosity. This indicates that it may be used in place of vegetable oil in the same amount as specified in the recipe. You may still use olive oil instead of butter or any other oil or fat your recipe asks for.

However, you should be aware of any possible issues while making brownies using olive oil! First off, olive oil has a richer taste than butter or vegetable oil. When baked, this may have a bitter flavor, yet sometimes it pairs very well with dark chocolate tastes. Knowing which kind of olive oil is ideal for baking is crucial since various varieties have distinct tastes. Additionally, olive oil tends to burn at lower temperatures compared to other oils and fats. So additional caution must be used while cooking with it. 

6 Other Substitutes For Vegetable Oil In Brownies

1. Canola Oil 

Canola oil is the easiest and most direct vegetable oil substitution for the brownie mix. Canola oil has a neutral flavor that compliments vegetable oil and won’t interfere with the flavor of your brownies. Additionally, it has a consistency similar to vegetable oil, maintaining the consistency of the brownies.

Canola oil is more popular than vegetable oil since it’s healthier. It lowers cholesterol and lowers the chance of developing heart disease. Canola oil may be substituted 1:1. For brownies, you would swap 1/2 cup of canola oil for 1/2 cup of vegetable oil.

2. Apple Sauce

Apple sauce is a terrific substitute for vegetable oil in brownie recipes and is something you probably already have in your kitchen. In addition to being a delectable condiment, apple sauce may be substituted for the moistening ingredient in cakes, muffins, cookies, and brownies.

Use a ratio of three-quarters of a cup to one cup while creating your brownies, and you should also slightly cut down on the sugar. You should avoid overdoing an already sweet dish as the apple sauce will likely offer some sweetness from the sugars it contains.

3. Avocado Oil

When making brownies, avocado oil is a perfect replacement for vegetable oil if you seek something healthier. Because avocado oil is unrefined, rich in healthful fat and vitamin E, and has a higher smoke point than other cooking oils, it may be used to fry various foods.

You won’t taste the difference in your brownie batter as much since avocado oil has a milder flavor than the common nut oils, such as peanut and hazelnut oil. But regrettably, it often costs more than vegetable oil and is seen as more costly since it is typically difficult to get and produced in smaller quantities.

Recommended Avocado Oil

Spectrum Naturals Oil Canola Refined Organic

[easyazon_image align=”center” height=”500″ identifier=”B0797GJYX9″ locale=”US” src=”” tag=”realikal-20″ width=”500″]

This oil is made from the squeezed flesh of avocados and has a high smoke point, making it ideal for nearly any culinary application in the kitchen. Avocado oil is low in polyunsaturated fats and contains one of the best concentrations of beneficial monounsaturated fats of any oil. Because of its mild flavor’s versatility, avocado oil is the ideal healthy substitution for all baked items. 

4. Sunflower Oil

If you have sunflower oil at home, then you can use it. Since sunflower oil is a key component of most vegetable oils, it works as a flavorless alternative in any brownie recipe. The non-volatile oil extracted from sunflower seeds is known as sunflower oil. Sunflower oil is often used as a frying oil and is rich in vitamin E. However, as sunflower oil has a stronger flavor than vegetable oil and should normally be used sparingly, you’ll want to use it carefully.

Recommended Sunflower Oil

La Tourangelle Organic Regenerative Sunflower Oil

[easyazon_image align=”center” height=”500″ identifier=”B01N13IJJ3″ locale=”US” src=”” tag=”realikal-20″ width=”500″]

Your kitchen and home benefit from the artisan expertise of La Tourangelle. La Tourangelle’s natural, artisanal oils are characterized by a premium flavor from the highest caliber components. This oil is a  suitable replacement for regular oil in baking. It can be used in place of canola oil and vegetable olive oil.

5. Yogurt

Did you know that yogurt is a fantastic breakfast dish and a fantastic substitute for a rich, creamy brownie batter? Probiotics, protein, and calcium are all abundant in yogurt. Yogurt is linked to improved immune system performance, healthy weight control, and decreased inflammation; thus, consistently ingesting it has various health advantages.

Yogurt is a great dairy food you probably already have in your refrigerator, and it also works well as a brownie replacement. However, because you don’t want other tastes to overpower the delicious chocolate flavor, you should always use plain yogurt rather than flavored yogurt.

6. Margarine Or Butter

Butter or melted margarine are often used in place of vegetable oil in brownie recipes. Both butter and oil will provide a moist, delicate texture when baking brownies, but only butter will give the dish the aeration necessary for brownies to rise effectively.

Butter is often considered a superior choice when using cake brownies since it makes the batter rise! However, the sort of brownies you want to create will also influence which choice you choose. Oil is usually preferred for brownies that are thicker and fudge-like. To keep the same taste and texture, use the same amount of butter as the amount of vegetable oil called for in the recipe. However, bake the brownies for two minutes longer than normal.

Why Do Brownies Need Oil?

Brownies are a preferred option for many home bakers, regardless of skill level or if you’re experimenting with different recipe ideas. You’ve undoubtedly noticed that the majority of brownie recipes include ingredients that are similar to one another, with a few minor exceptions. In a typical brownie recipe, ingredients include flour, sugar, eggs, chocolate, and vegetable oil.

Why, therefore, do brownies need oil? The essential component that gives brownies their soft, gooey texture and prevents lumps from developing in the batter is oil.

Typically, vegetable oil is used since it has a fairly neutral flavor and won’t overpower the taste of the rich chocolate. Unlike solid fats like butter, oil is a liquid. Thus it will keep the batter smooth and bubble-free.

Downsides Of Using Olive Oil For Brownies

Vegetable oil, as previously said, has a very neutral and mild flavor, so you won’t notice it when eating your brownies. Conversely, olive oil has a stronger, more overt flavor that could be detected in the brownies. Olive oil is often somewhat bitter when used in baked products, which is not what you want for your brownies! Use a mild olive oil rather than a potent extra virgin oil to prevent this.

Additionally, be sure to get a reputable brand of oil. Olive oils that are less expensive and less well-known tend to have stronger flavors. Speaking of olive oil brands, you may be surprised by how much more expensive olive oil is than vegetable oil. Vegetable oil is far less costly than olive oil, which will undoubtedly drive up the price of your brownies. Keep that in mind when putting a few teaspoons of that fine olive oil into the brownie recipe!

Conclusion On Can I Substitute Olive Oil For Vegetable Oil In Brownies

Olive oil can be used to bake brownies, so do not panic if you are preparing brownies and only have a bottle on hand. Consider these suggestions to ensure that the brownies that come out of the oven are precisely what you anticipate. And don’t be scared to explore while preparing brownies with various vegetable oil replacements. There is undoubtedly a range of culinary techniques and recipes that you can master since there are so many options available. You never know, you may stumble upon a substitute that ends up being your new favorite and works better for you! Safflower, grapeseed, soybean, and coconut oils may also be used in place of vegetable oil.