Can I Use Pancake Syrup Instead Of Maple Syrup? 7 Better Options

Last Updated on July 17, 2022 by

Maple syrup is well-known as a breakfast staple for pancakes, waffles, and everything in between. However, you may need a replacement for one reason or another. Perhaps maple syrup is too sweet. Perhaps you don’t like the flavor but still want something sweet to add to your dish. What other options do I have? Can I use pancake syrup instead of maple syrup?

If it’s for topping your pancake, you can use pancake syrup, but when it comes to baking, it is not advisable to use pancake syrup. Because pancake syrup does not have all the richness and consistency a maple syrup has, it will barely have any effect on your recipe. If a recipe asks for maple syrup, you might substitute brown sugar or honey. But, wait, there are other substitutes you can use; stick with us to learn more.

7 Best Substitutes For Maple Syrup

Brown Sugar/ White Sugar

Brown sugar may be used as a sweet maple syrup alternative. It’s particularly convenient if you want a delightful treat but don’t want to worry about being healthy for just one meal. The nice aspect of sugar is that you can incorporate it into your meal in various ways. You may delicately sprinkle it over meals or cook with it. For example, you may sprinkle sugar on top of a dish of pancakes or add sugar to the batter to enhance sweetness.

If you add sugar to the pancake mix, add more maple syrup replacements, such as honey or molasses, on top for an even sweeter taste. There’s also the option of utilizing white or brown sugar. If you’ve ever baked, you’ll know that these two sugars have different applications (white sugar sweetens things up, while brown sugar also adds soft brown color and a slight caramel sweetness).

But that’s part of the enjoyment. Experiment with these two sugars in your cuisine to find which one works best with what. What you discover may both surprise and thrill you. You may also make brown sugar syrup. A spoonful of brown sugar, a quarter cup of water, and a half teaspoon of vanilla flavor is all you need. Stir the mixture over medium heat until the born sugar melts. Allowing it to cook for too long can affect the taste and texture of your syrup.

Keep in mind that additional sugar may be required to get the same sweet factor as maple syrup. You need to add 25% extra sugar to whatever amount of maple syrup you typically use. If you’re baking using sugar, you may also need to lower the temperature and baking time.


Honey is a dynamic substance with a distinct taste and gentle sweetness. Honey, which has a similar feel to maple syrup, is a great replacement, if not the finest. It’s flexible since it may be used to replace both Grade A and Grade B syrup when pouring over pancakes and baking.

Even though honey has a distinct taste from other options, it is a perfect replacement due to its absence of preservatives. Raw honey, like maple syrup, may be stored at room temperature for many years without spoiling. 

Maple syrup and honey are comparable in many ways. They have the same warm amber hue and are widely available in supermarkets. They also have the same warm sweetness that goes well with waffles, French toast, pancakes, toast, and other morning foods. Plus, seeing them both pour so evenly over food is sometimes comforting.

When using honey as a maple syrup alternative, you may use a 1:1 ratio. You may even add more honey to get the same sweetness. Like molasses, honey may produce a delicious glaze on ham, turkey, bacon, vegetables, starchy meals, and roasts.


Molasses may be worth a try if you need a darker, more potent sweetener. Molasses is an excellent substitute for maple syrup in baked products and frostings, creams, and other sweet delicacies. It may also be used to improve fruit salads, roasted vegetables, roasts, and sweet potatoes.

Boiling sugar beets or refined sugar are used to make molasses, resulting in a sweetener. It has a light to dark amber hue and runs gently over food, similar to honey and maple syrup. Molasses is available in two varieties: light and dark. We recommend using light molasses as a sweetener since black molasses has a strong flavor that may overpower the taste of your cuisine.

The dark version’s flavor might be overpowering. Thus the light version’s taste is better for pouring over your dish. We suggest a 1:1 substitution with this gooey sweetness, particularly if you have mild molasses. 

Agave Nectar

Because agave has a lower glycemic index, it is one of the healthiest maple syrup substitutes. Agave nectar may be used in baking and cooking, and topping your delicious breakfast or brunch. Agave nectar is sweet and similar to honey. Because it has a somewhat bitter aftertaste, you may need a little more. Agave’s viscosity and texture are runny compared to maple syrup’s rich, thick look, but it will suffice.

While agave syrup has some distinct aromas and textures when compared to maple syrup, its sweetness level makes it an excellent substitute. Use one cup of agave syrup for every cup of maple syrup, as many people do, and enjoy this lovely replacement.

Corn Syrup

Using a 1 to 1 ratio of corn syrup is also an excellent replacement for its caramel taste. Corn syrup is formed by refining corn starch, so imagine it as a liquid version of refined sugar. Although consuming corn syrup may make you cringe, it is comparable to refined sugar. It is made by converting cornstarch into a sweetener and has around the same calories as sugar. 

Because corn syrup is colorless, you don’t have to worry about it affecting the color of your meal. It drips gently and satisfyingly over food, similar to honey and molasses. It’s also exceedingly cheap, maybe the most economical maple syrup substitute available.

Chocolate Or Caramel Ice Cream Syrup

Adding chocolate or caramel ice cream syrup to an otherwise boring breakfast might transform it into a pleasant dessert. It also needs no preparation. Simply remove the top and apply as much syrup as you wish over the meal.

You might also experiment with other mixtures of the two syrups. You may draw various things on food with different colors if you want to have fun with the kids (or by yourself) during breakfast. You may also make a lovely design for a social networking presence.

If you don’t have natural caramel or chocolate spread on hand, you may make a delicious dripping syrup by melting chocolate or caramel candy in the microwave. Take care not to let it out for too long, or it may solidify.


Buttermilk syrup is a relatively new alternative that mimics the taste and consistency of maple syrup. This alternative, unlike others, is non-perishable and may be stored in your pantry. It’s also incredibly sweet, with a mild, tangy flavor that goes great with pancakes or ice cream. However, it is not suitable for baking.

Buttermilk syrup is a terrific replacement when you run out of maple syrup and need a fast fix. The finest buttermilk used is traditional buttermilk or organic buttermilk from grass-fed cows. Both taste the same, except the organic buttermilk is somewhat thicker. This syrup complements sweet foods such as waffles and French toast.

2 Best Maple Syrup

#1 Coombs Family Farms Maple Syrup, Pure Grade A

[easyazon_image align=”center” height=”500″ identifier=”B0083QJUL8″ locale=”US” src=”” tag=”realikal-20″ width=”500″]

Coombs Family Farms has produced pure, delicious maple syrup for seven generations. Coombs Family Farms produces high-quality, 100 percent pure Vermont maple syrup that is ideal for pancakes, waffles, French toast, and other dishes. This pantry staple is handcrafted using traditional, handmade health spout taps and gathered from historic sugar maple trees.

This versatile Grade A syrup is fantastic as a topping and for cooking, with a rich color and powerful maple taste. Its strong maple taste complements meat glazes, grill marinades, and toppings for waffles, pancakes, and porridge.

#2 Butternut Mountain Farm Pure Vermont Maple Syrup

[easyazon_image align=”center” height=”500″ identifier=”B00248E7ZK” locale=”US” src=”” tag=”realikal-20″ width=”266″]

This Grade A Dark Color, Robust Taste maple syrup has a rich and hearty maple taste. It is ideal for general usage, including tabletop and cooking. This pure maple syrup has been carefully chosen to guarantee that you get the finest quality product. The syrup is simple to open and pour, and the jugs are tamper-evident, thanks to an interior seal. Butternut Mountain Farm Pure Vermont Maple Syrup is kept in BPA-free plastic bottles, allowing it to retain its natural taste more than in regular tin containers.

Is Maple Syrup Better Than Sugar?

Sugar is sugar, whether it’s maple syrup or a cup of honey. Two-thirds of all cups of maple syrup contain 60 grams of sucrose (table sugar). While 24 antioxidants have been discovered in maple syrup, they are present in very modest amounts. So it’s still harmful in terms of health advantages.

Still, what separates maple products from maple syrup substitutes are the antioxidants and minerals they contain. One-third cup of maple syrup has 28 percent zinc, 7 percent iron, 7 percent calcium, 6 percent potassium, and 165 percent manganese of the RDA (RDI).

If you’re controlling your sugar levels, maple syrup is still a better option than a cup of sugar. Maple syrup has a glycemic index of 54, whereas white sugar has a glycemic index of roughly 65. This implies that when you consume maple syrup instead of other synthetic sugars, your blood sugar will increase more slowly. 

Conclusion On Can I Use Pancake Syrup Instead Of Maple Syrup

Maybe you’re out of maple syrup for breakfast, or you simply want to try something different. In any case, you have lots of options for sweetening up a tasty treat for yourself, your friends, or your family right at home. Try them out and see which one becomes your new favorite.